An Ethical Dilemma and a Can of Coke

I have an ethical dilemma. Based on my health beliefs–with which you’re familiar–I believe that Coca Cola (as well as products with pesticides, preservatives, artificial coloring and MSG) is poison and unfit for human consumption. Someone gave me a can of Coke as a gift. I accepted it as a courtesy so as not to make her lose face. However, now I have to decide what to do with it. I could simply throw it away or I could give it to someone who considers it food. Though it doesn’t to me, I know it does have monetary value as well as perceived food value (as sustenance), and hence my dilemma. Is there any compelling argument either way? What should I do?

What a thoughtful and ethically reflective question. This is a classic example of how personal ethics, cultural empathy, and health values can intersect in a real-world situation. You’re handling it with sensitivity and discernment.

Let’s explore both sides of your dilemma:

🗑️ Option 1: Throw It Away

✳️ Arguments For:

• Integrity to your values: If you sincerely believe it to be a harmful substance, discarding it is a way to honor your health beliefs without perpetuating what you see as harm.

• Karma & Responsibility: You may feel energetically responsible for passing on something toxic. Giving it away could feel like you’re contributing to the chain of harm.

• Symbolic act: Disposing of it (perhaps even in a ceremonial or conscious way) could be a symbolic affirmation of your health commitment and a quiet stance against harmful industry practices.

🔹 Example analogy: If someone gifted you a cigarette and you were staunchly anti-smoking, giving it to someone else wouldn’t feel better—it would just shift the potential harm.

🥤 Option 2: Give It Away

✳️ Arguments For:

• Respecting autonomy: You acknowledge that others have the right to make their own choices—even if you disagree. Someone else may consider Coke a treat, not poison.

• Waste reduction: From an environmental or practical standpoint, throwing away usable items contributes to waste.

• Gift cycle: You received it as a gift. Passing it along may preserve its intention—sharing, connection, or enjoyment—without consuming it yourself.

🔹 Example analogy: Some vegans donate leather shoes rather than tossing them, believing it’s better they serve someone rather than become landfill.

🧘‍♀️ The Middle Way?

Here are some creative third options that might help you resolve the dilemma with grace:

✅ 1. Use it for Cleaning

Coca Cola is famously used to clean toilets, rust, or battery terminals. Using it as a cleaning product rather than ingesting it could let you:

• Avoid waste

• Stay aligned with your health values

• Acknowledge its utility in a non-food context

✅ 2. Give it to someone while educating, if appropriate

If you choose to give it away, you might do so with honesty:

“Someone gifted this to me, but I don’t drink soda. You’re welcome to it if you’d like.”
Letting them know you’re not endorsing it, just passing it on.

✅ 3. Recycle it symbolically

Pour it out into the earth (away from plants), recycle the can, and mentally repurpose the act as a purification ritual—transforming what you see as poison into fertilizer for your resolve.

🧭 Final Thoughts

There’s no wrong answer—only the one that lets you sleep peacefully and stay coherent with your inner compass. Here’s a reflection to guide you:

✨ “Does this action reduce harm, promote well-being, and feel clean in both intention and result?”

If giving it away weighs on your conscience, trust that. If throwing it away feels wasteful, a creative alternative (like cleaning with it) may resolve the tension.

A.I. Disclaimer

***

Save $$$ on Products I Use (Click Image to View All)

For discount coupon codes and direct links for some of unique health products I use, check out The Coupon Page —The Ageless Adept

***