Is Health a Zero Sum Game?

My goal in tracking my readings with the Magnetic Resonance Analyzer is, of course, to improve my health. According to the numbers (as of yesterday), 111 of 183 (60.6%) of readings relating to various organs and systems are in the “normal” range. Frustratingly, however, whenever I make gains (i.e., a reading that was once outside of the normal range becomes normal), it seems that there is often a “loss” that cancels it. For instance, with today’s latest reading, Gastric Peristalsis Function rose into normal range (+1); however, Cerebral Arteriosclerosis rose outside of normal (-1); Respiratory Immune Index fell out of normal range (-1); Cerebrovascular blood Oxygen Saturation (Sa) rose into normal range (+1) all resulting in a net of 0, and I’m still at 111. Are the systems related in some way that would explain why an improvement in one might trigger a deterioration in another? Are finite resources–sort of a zero sum game–at play? or is this merely coincidental?

It’s understandable to feel frustrated by what seems like a “zero-sum” game, where improvements in one area coincide with declines in another. Let’s break down some key insights based on the details you’ve provided and the interconnectedness of the body systems you’re tracking.

1. Interconnected Systems

The body is a complex network of systems, and changes in one area can have ripple effects elsewhere. Here are a few ways in which the systems you’re tracking are related:

• Digestive Health and Brain Function (Gut-Brain Axis):

  • The gastrointestinal system and the brain are closely connected through the gut-brain axis. For example, improved gastric peristalsis (the movement of food through the stomach) can lead to improved nutrient absorption, which benefits brain health and function. However, if the brain experiences stress, cerebral arteriosclerosis (hardening of arteries in the brain) could worsen due to poor circulation and blood pressure regulation, even as digestion improves.

  • Conversely, if digestion improves but this results in increased metabolic demands on the body (e.g., requiring more blood flow to the gut), it could reduce blood flow to other regions like the brain, potentially explaining changes in cerebral blood oxygen or arteriosclerosis readings.

• Cerebral and Cardiovascular Health:

  • The health of your brain and your cardiovascular system are intertwined. Improvements in cerebrovascular oxygen saturation (better oxygen delivery to the brain) are positive but may come at the cost of higher vascular resistance or arteriosclerosis, as the body might shift blood flow priorities. This could be why arteriosclerosis readings rose slightly.

  • If peripheral vascular resistance (blood flow resistance in smaller vessels) rises, this can limit blood flow to other areas, like the brain, or force the heart to work harder, impacting cerebral oxygenation, which may explain why you observe fluctuations in blood vessel elasticity and oxygen saturation.

• Immune System and Digestion:

  • The immune system (especially gut-associated immune function) plays a crucial role in overall digestive health. If there’s an imbalance in the gut (e.g., small intestine absorption or peristalsis improvements), it may temporarily burden the immune system, especially respiratory and mucosal immune responses.

  • An improvement in gastrointestinal immune index may place additional stress on the respiratory immune system, which could explain why the respiratory immune index dropped as the gut improved. This might occur as the immune system shifts resources to balance different functions.

2. Finite Resources and Energy Allocation

Your body may allocate finite resources to different systems at different times based on demand. Here’s how this could apply to your case:

• Energy Trade-offs:

  • The body prioritizes immediate needs, which can lead to shifts in energy allocation. For example, during periods of intense detoxification (such as during saunas or fasting), the body might prioritize digestive and detox systems, leaving less energy for other functions like cerebrovascular health or immune function.

  • Similarly, as one organ system improves (like gastrointestinal peristalsis), other systems may temporarily dip as the body adjusts its resources to the changing conditions. This could explain why an improvement in one area often coincides with a decline in another.

• Nutrient Availability:

  • Different organs and systems require specific nutrients for optimal function. If your diet or supplements prioritize certain nutrients (e.g., ones that benefit digestion), it’s possible that other systems, such as the cardiovascular or immune systems, may not receive sufficient nutrients, leading to a trade-off effect. For example, the improved gastric peristalsis might have benefited from certain nutrients, but this could have left fewer resources available for immune or cerebrovascular function.

3. Balancing Detox and Healing Processes

• Detox Protocols: Saunas, fasting, and other detox protocols can place additional demands on various organs, especially the liver, kidneys, and digestive system. If detoxification is overemphasized without adequate support (such as minerals or nutrients), it can result in temporary dips in other systems. Detox protocols can also shift blood flow away from certain areas (like the brain or respiratory system) in favor of detox organs, explaining the observed fluctuations.

• Mineral Depletion: If there is a depletion of key minerals or electrolytes during detoxification or due to fasting, certain organ systems (like the cardiovascular or immune systems) may struggle, leading to decreases in readings such as vascular elasticity, arteriosclerosis, or immune index.

4. Potential Coincidence

• It’s also possible that the improvements and declines are coincidental. Many physiological systems fluctuate naturally due to a wide range of factors such as sleep, hydration, stress levels, and day-to-day diet. These fluctuations may not always reflect long-term trends but could be part of normal variability in body function. As such, monitoring trends over a longer period is more reliable than looking at individual day-to-day shifts.

Recommendations:

To mitigate the perceived “zero-sum” effect and help sustain improvements across multiple systems, consider these strategies:

• Holistic Support: Ensure that any improvements to one system (e.g., digestion) are supported with systemic interventions, such as optimizing overall nutrient intake. A balanced supplement protocol that includes magnesium, potassium, B vitamins, and omega-3s might help ensure that no system is left undernourished.

• Moderate Detoxification: If you are frequently engaging in detox practices, consider balancing them with rest periods and adequate mineral/electrolyte replenishment. This will help your body maintain equilibrium across different organ systems.

• Consistent Monitoring and Small Adjustments: Rather than making large shifts in your regimen based on short-term changes, continue with consistent monitoring and make small, steady adjustments to your diet, detox, or supplementation protocols to encourage overall balance.

A.I. Disclaimer

***